As a lifelong fan of the romantic comedy genre, I have seen many, many times how the search for love can take you down all kinds of twisty trails. But John C. Reilly’s adventure in Mister Romantic definitely qualifies as one of the most absurdly funny love quests I’ve been on. We knew we were in for something a bit off kilter when the musicians, dressed in old-timey black suits, strolled down the aisle and up to the stage in a dirge-like, funeral march–style as they entered the June 7th show at the Lobero.
A trunk is dragged onstage, and out pops our star in all of his loopy, ginormous Bozo-haired glory. “Hello, I’m Mister Romantic,” said Riley, seamlessly embodying the persona of his sweet, dopey character. He explained his quest to the audience: “I can stay in the box, or put on a show. And I don’t have to go back in if I can find one person who will love me forever.”
That’s the basic conceit of Mister Romantic, as Reilly explained to me in our interview earlier this spring (read here ). But hearing about it is one thing, and seeing it in person is another. I’m completely charmed as — after pointing to the band and saying, “I don't know who these people are, but I hope they know the same songs I do” — they launch into a solid rendition of “Dream When You’re Feeling Blue,” with Reilly singing a strong lead and launching into even stronger comedic dance and pantomime during the instrumental sections.